Translate

Thursday, August 28, 2025

THE POPE, NOT ACTING LIKE A POLITICIAN USING POLITICAL PARTY TALKING POINTS, CALLS FRENCH POLITICIANS TO EXERCISE THEIR ROLES AS FRENCH POLITICIANS AS ROMAN CATHOLICS AND NOT TO SEPARATE THEIR CATHOLICISM FROM THEIR POLITICS!



The following is a summary of Pope Leo’s remarks to a group of French politicians provided by Silere non possum. My most humble brilliant remarks embedded in their text summary in (red)

The full text translated into English, is well worth reading, which I post below the summary:

 Vatican City – This morning, Pope Leo XIV received a delegation of French political figures from the Diocese of Créteil, led by Bishop Dominique Blanchet, in the Consistory Hall. The meeting took place in a cordial atmosphere: opening his remarks, Leo joked with his guests, saying in English: "I'm sure many of you speak English, no? I am going to attempt to speak French, counting on your benevolence!", then choosing to address them entirely in their own language.

Politics and Faith: "There Are Not Two Persons in One"

The Pope focused on a crucial theme: the relationship between faith and political responsibility. "Monsignor Blanchet asked me to give you some advice. In reality, I can only give you one, but it is crucial: unite yourselves ever more closely to Jesus, live by Him, and bear witness to Him. There is no public figure divided in two: on one side, the politician, on the other, the Christian. No. There exists the politician who, under the gaze of God and in conscience, lives out his commitments and responsibilities in a Christian manner. (This is what Vatican II asked of all lay Catholics, politicians and otherwise, to bring our Catholic Faith and Morals to the public square, politics, home, work, play!)

Leo XIV thus reiterated that Christianity cannot be relegated to the private or intimate sphere, but must permeate every dimension of life, including the public and legislative spheres.

Social Doctrine and the Courage to Bear Witness

The Pontiff then encouraged the French representatives not to fear applying and defending the Church's social doctrine with conviction, emphasizing its consistency with natural law, recognizable by all, even non-believers: "You are called to strengthen yourselves in faith, to deepen your knowledge of the Church's social doctrine, and to apply it in the exercise of your functions and in the drafting of laws. It is fully in harmony with human nature [...]. You must not be afraid to propose and defend it with conviction: it is a doctrine of salvation, oriented to the good of every person and the construction of peaceful, harmonious, prosperous, and reconciled societies." (This is key and Pope Leo knows it, that in the secular, political realm, we must rely upon Natural Law! It is great hearing a pope, once again, calling us to follow natural law as an antidote to so many of the societal problems today! Calling politicians to defend the doctrine of salvation!) 

The Critique of Sterile Secularism

A particularly relevant passage of the speech concerned the French context. Leo XIV emphasized how, due to an often misunderstood secularism, it is not easy for a self-declared Christian politician to act and decide in accordance with his faith: "Your pilgrimage is not only a personal experience of enrichment, but it has great value and utility for the men and women you serve. And it is even more meritorious because, in France, it is not easy for a public representative—due to an often misunderstood secularism—to act and decide in accordance with his faith." (While this is certainly true of France since the French Revolution, it is also true of the USA and there are few Catholics in elected office in the USA who are doing what Pope Leo is asking! Just think of the most pernicious things that Biden, Pelosi and others have promoted and still claim to be good Catholics proudly receiving Holy Communion!)

Finally, the Pope clearly denounced the ideological pressures, party logic, and "cultural colonization" that make it increasingly difficult to live the Gospel in politics. "Courage is needed: the courage to say 'no, I can't,' when the truth is at stake," he warned. Absolutely! (Thank you Pope Leo and thank you for emphasizing Catholicism, as is your vocation, rather than a particular political party’s talking points, no matter how meritorious those talking points are. As a priest and bishop, you know your vocation and it isn’t political. That’s the vocation of the Catholic layman! Thanks for letting us know Christendom no longer exists and the clergy no longer run the world. The clergy’s role is to call the laity to sanctity and to live the Catholic Faith where they are planted!)

Here is the full text of the pope’s speech to French politicians but a google translate of the Italian text:

In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Peace be with you!

I'm sure many of you speak English, right? I am going to attempt to speak French, counting on your benevolence!

I cordially greet His Excellency Archbishop Dominique Blanchet, and I welcome all of you, elected officials and civil leaders of the Diocese of Créteil, on your pilgrimage to Rome.

I am happy to welcome you on your journey of faith: return to your daily commitments strengthened by hope, more steadfast in working to build a more just, more humane, more fraternal world, which can only be a world more imbued with the Gospel. Faced with the various deviations experienced by our Western societies, we, as Christians, cannot do better than turn to Christ and ask for his help in carrying out our responsibilities.

For this reason, your journey, more than simply a matter of personal enrichment, is of great importance and of great benefit to the men and women you serve. This is all the more praiseworthy because, due to a sometimes misunderstood secularism, it is not easy for an elected official in France to act and decide consistently with his faith in the exercise of public responsibilities.

The salvation that Jesus achieved through his death and resurrection encompasses all dimensions of human life, such as culture, economics and work, family and marriage, respect for human dignity and life, health, and even communication, education, and politics. Christianity cannot be reduced to a simple private devotion, because it involves a way of living in society marked by the love of God and neighbor, who, in Christ, is no longer an enemy but a brother.

Your region, the place of your commitments, must address major social issues such as violence in some neighborhoods, insecurity, precariousness, drug networks, unemployment, the disappearance of conviviality… To address these issues, Christian leaders are strengthened by the virtue of charity that has indwelled them since their baptism. Charity is a gift from God, a “power capable of inspiring new ways to address the problems of today's world and profoundly renewing structures, social organizations, and legal systems from within. From this perspective, charity becomes social and political charity: social charity makes us love the common good and effectively seek the good of all people” (Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church, n. 207). This is why Christian leaders are better prepared to face the challenges of today's world, naturally to the extent that they live and bear witness to the faith at work within them, their personal relationship with Christ who enlightens them and gives them this strength. Jesus states it forcefully: “Because without me you can do nothing” (Jn 15:5); We should therefore not be surprised that the promotion of “values” — however evangelical they may be — but “emptied” of Christ who is their author, are incapable of changing the world.

So, Monsignor Blanchet asked me for some advice. The first—and only—advice I would give you is to unite yourselves ever more closely to Jesus, to live by him and bear witness to him. There is no separation in the personality of a public figure: there is not the politician on one side and the Christian on the other. But there is the politician who, under the gaze of God and his conscience, lives his commitments and responsibilities in a Christian manner!

You are therefore called to strengthen yourselves in faith, to deepen your knowledge of the doctrine—particularly the social doctrine—that Jesus taught the world, and to put it into practice in the exercise of your functions and in the drafting of laws. Its foundations are essentially in harmony with human nature, the natural law that everyone can recognize, even non-Christians, even non-believers. Therefore, there is no need to be afraid to propose and defend it with conviction: it is a doctrine of salvation that aims at the good of every human being, at the building of peaceful, harmonious, prosperous, and reconciled societies.

I am well aware that the openly Christian commitment of a public official is not easy, especially in certain Western societies where Christ and his Church are marginalized, often ignored, sometimes ridiculed. Nor am I unaware of the pressures, party directives, and "ideological colonizations"—to borrow a fitting expression from Pope Francis—to which politicians are subjected. They must have courage: the courage to say at times, "No, I can't!" when the truth is at stake. Here too, only union with Jesus—Jesus crucified!—will give you the courage to suffer in his name. He said this to his disciples: "In the world you will have tribulation, but take heart; I have overcome the world!" (Jn 16:33).

Dear friends, I thank you for your visit and assure you of my most sincere encouragement as you continue your work in the service of your fellow citizens. Maintain the hope of a better world; Remain certain that, united with Christ, your efforts will bear fruit and be rewarded. I entrust you and your country to the protection of Our Lady of the Assumption, and I cordially impart my Apostolic Blessing to you.


12 comments:

TJM said...

More bad news for the fake Dem politicians

big benny said...

Not exactly, Republicans and Trump populists aren’t acting according to Catholic social teaching either.

Mark Thomas said...

Will Catholic politicians obey Pope Leo XIV's call to promote Catholic teachings within the public square? Pope Francis (requiescat in pace) presented that message, to little effect, to Catholic politicians.

Example: From AI Overview:

"Pope Francis has repeatedly stressed that Catholic politicians should be guided by the Church's teachings, arguing that faith should not be a "marginal or private" matter, but should influence their public duties.

=======

July 7, 2024 A.D.

-- Pope Francis: In politics, Catholics cannot live a ‘private faith’

Pope Francis on Sunday urged Catholics to share their faith in the public square, and to combat political polarization by supporting person-centered democracy.

=======

August 29, 2017 A.D.

-- Pope Francis: Catholic politicians should be guided by the church’s moral and social teachings

"Catholic politicians should be guided by the church’s moral and social teachings when crafting legislation, Pope Francis said."

=======

Pax.

Mark Thomas

Mark said...

As Big Benny correctly observes, “Republicans and Trump populists aren’t acting according to Catholic social teaching either.” Although I would need to see the relevant official documents to reach a definitive judgment, my provisional judgment based on news reports such as the one linked below is that Stephen Miller’s cruelty knows no limits (I think we can reasonably assume that the deeply unwell Miller is behind this latest move in his cruel and heartless anti-immigrant crusade, one which targets ALL undocumented immigrants, not just the criminal elements and gang members):

https://www.the-independent.com/news/world/americas/us-politics/trump-fema-undocumented-immigrants-disaster-relief-b2816090.html#comments-area

Mark J.

Fr. Allan J. McDonald said...

Of course Trump isn’t Catholic whereas Biden was and thus there would be different expectations. But yes, Catholics in politics like our VP should be more sensitive to what the pope is saying and saying clearly.

Fr. Allan J. McDonald said...

We know that Biden did not follow Catholic teachings on one non-negotiable and that is abortion. Neither does Pelosi. Others are in the same class. The point isn’t if Catholics will obey but that the pope is very clear about the principles that should motivate Catholic politicians and others of goodwill. I hope that Pope Leo will encourage bishops to deny Holy Communion to Catholic politicians who promote non-negotiable as it concerns Catholic teachings, the murder of children is one of them.

Nick said...

Of course, Mark Thomas will ignore that Pelosi gleefully received Holy Communion at the Vatican after being barred from the Sacrament by her bishop.

MT can quote nice words all he wants, but the talk wasn't walked, many different ways.

Nick

Mark said...

Father McDonald:

I am not quite sure what you mean here by “different expectations.” Trump is whatever he is, and Stephen Miller is Jewish, so that lets them off the hook? Surely your position cannot be that only Catholics are subject to moral obligations identified and articulated by the Church. That is certainly not your position regarding abortion and certain other issues. Or are the Church’s teachings on those issues universally binding “non-negotiables” (as you phrase it in a later thread) whereas other aspects of the Church’s social teaching are not and therefore “negotiable”? But I don’t think that can be your position either because it certainly isn’t the position of the Pope or the USCCB as I understand it. Can you please clarify? Thanks.

Mark J.


Fr. Allan J. McDonald said...

Mark, The Pope and/or Church has/have no control over politicians, Catholic or otherwise. Pope Leo certainly gave a good talk to Catholic politicians to not separate their faith from their politics. It is all very nice, but unfortunately tea and crumpets way of evangelizing. Non Catholics will follow the voters and pander to them as do Catholics. Catholics who promote the most egregious form of the culture of death, abortion, and wear that moniker proudly so be prohibited from receiving Holy Communion and in some cases public excommunication is appropriate. That probably wouldn’t matter to them. If the Democrats party becomes more strident in its culture of death, I think it should rank up there with the KKK and other organizations that Catholics are forbidden from joining, especially priests. You can’t say you support the KKK in their good things, except for their racism. You can’t support democrats in their good things, except for their promotion of the genocide of unborn children.

big benny said...

Likewise can you say you support the Republicans except for their racism, xenophobia and relentless assault on the poor and homeless?

Fr. Allan J. McDonald said...

Let’s be clear, I am an independent and would never belong to either the Democrat or republican parties. I follow what Pope Francis recommended Americans do at our last election, to vote for the lesser of two evils. When it came to Trump and Harris, Harris is rabidly pro-choice and wanted no limits whatsoever on abortion. She promoted the choice to murder children without limits. Trump’s position is more moderate. He is the lesser of the two evils. BTW, Pope Francis inserting himself into the American election helped Trump to get elected by his statement on the choice between the lesser of two evils.

big benny said...

Do you think coz many interpreted his lesser of two evils comment to be a nod towards Harris!