If Bishop Vesco is opposed to the OCIA and making converts because he is opposed to evangelization, then he should be condemned not only by Bishop Barron, but all bishops and the Bishop of Rome, Pope Leo.
But I will give Cardinal Vesco the benefit of the doubt. Maybe he is opposed to proselytizing rather than to evangelization which all Catholic Bishops should be to include Bishop Barron.
This is AI’s description of the difference between the two:
Evangelization is the respectful sharing of the Christian Gospel that invites a free, personal response to faith, whereas proselytizing uses pressure, manipulation, or coercion to recruit members.
Evangelization
• Core Focus: Proclaiming the "good news" of Jesus Christ, salvation, and God's love.
• Method: Relies on witness, testimony, charity, dialogue, and respect for human freedom and conscience.
• Goal: To introduce people to a genuine relationship with God, allowing faith to grow by attraction rather than force.
• View of Conversion: True faith must be chosen freely; conversion is seen as the work of God/the Holy Spirit, not human salesmanship.
Proselytizing
• Core Focus: Increasing numbers, filling church pews, or meeting organizational quotas.
• Method: Often uses fear, guilt, unfair attacks on other faiths, or attaching strings (like financial aid or material benefits) to conversion.
• Goal: To pressure or convince someone to switch their religious label or join a specific group.
• View of Conversion: Treated like a transaction or a forced argument where compliance matters more than free will.
Pope Leo is not opposed to Evangelization but is opposed to proselytizing. If he were opposed to evangelization, he would not have authorized the beatification of the five Georgia Martyrs and he would have condemned every missionary the Church has sent to the new worldin North, Central and South America!
He would not have been a Bishop in Peru! He would not be pope!
If Cardinal Vesco is opposed to evangelization, he should be removed as the bishop of his diocese, no? And if Bishop Barron is in favor of proselytizing, he should be too, no?
At Sunday’s Angelus at St. Peter’s Square, Pope Leo said this:
After the Angelus
Dear brothers and sisters,
Yesterday, in Savannah, Georgia, in the United States of America, Pedro de Corpa and four companions, religious of the Order of Friars Minor, who were killed in odium fidei in 1597, were beatified. Originally from Spain, they responded generously to the Lord's call to evangelize the peoples of the Americas, even to the point of giving their lives. Let us invoke the intercession of these martyrs for all missionaries of the Gospel.
4 comments:
Proselytizing reminds me of some Catholic missionaries in China being accused of bribing the locals by offering them free rice as part of the "conversion process." They referred to this pool of converts as "rice Christians!"
Saint Junipero Serra, pray for us. Where would he have drawn the line?
How much proselytizing is actually being done? Bishop Vesco's comments aren't specific enough to allow me to conclude what exactly he is condemning. Jesus and the apostles were pretty specific in describing expectations for sharing the Gospel and the New Testament doesn't read like proselytization is being encouraged. Seems like that would take a whole lot of energy. Evangelizing is as much sharing and providing an example as anything else. Father Kentenich, the founder of the Schoenstatt Apostolic Movement, urged his parishioners to "live so that their lives would be irresistible question marks" to those around them, and to remain engaged with the world, not "disappear into the catacombs."
The discussions must make clear what they are discussing for the benefit of all involved, especially the layity who will read and contemplate the arguments.
Post a Comment