Translate

Sunday, November 22, 2026

THE POWER-PLAYS OF CLERICALISM AND AN ALTAR RAILING TEMPEST IN A TEAPOT

 





Where do I begin?

The Discastery of Divine Worship under the pen of Archbishop Viola has upheld where Holy Communion can be distributed in a diocese within my Province of Atlanta.

That diocese, under a new Franciscan bishop reversed what the still living previous bishop had generously allowed and in the most non-clerical way possible. Parishes could distribute Holy Communion to those kneeling at an altar railing or a kneeler but no one is to be denied Holy Communion who choose the norm of standing. 

Upholding the new bishop’s directives, Archbishop Viola states that communicants cannot choose a place to receive Holy Communion that is in a different place where the majority are receiving. But it emphasizes that Catholics have a right to receive Holy Communion kneeling.

This is a money quote from an Advaticanum commentary:

The fact that the minister did not distribute Holy Communion to you and your family when you chose to present yourselves at a place or in a manner different from that prescribed by the diocesan norms cannot be construed as an unlawful refusal to administer the Sacrament,” Archbishop Viola writes.

However, the Dicastery recognises that the faithful retain the right to kneel when receiving the Eucharist and that a minister cannot refuse Communion solely on that basis.

“Indeed, a true denial of Holy Communion would arise if a member of the faithful, presenting himself or herself according to the established manner of distribution, were refused the Sacrament solely because he or she chose to kneel at the moment of reception,” the letter states.

“Such, however, is not the situation presented in the present recourse.”

Thus, while the faithful may receive Communion kneeling, the right does not extend to requiring the celebrant or minister to distribute the Sacrament at an altar rail or another location contrary to the arrangements established by the diocesan bishop.

Apart from the altar-railing “thingy”, the good bishop has asked that kneelers be removed at the places of distributing Holy Communion too. This means that communicants who exercise their right to kneel to receive Holy Communion at the designated places must kneel on the floor. The good bishop could care less about the difficulty this presents to the communicants and is entirely mean-spirited and a mortal sin against charity. 

According to the good bishop’s legislation, those who are unable to approach designated stations due to poor health, wheel chairs, etc, cannot receive Holy Communion at their places in the congregation. Even at the TLM, I go to elderly, handicapped people, sometimes at the back the church to offer them Holy Communion. Under the good bishop’s rules, priests in that diocese can no longer do that! 

In the parishes in my Diocese of Savannah where the altar railing is used, those who wish not to kneel at the altar railing can still receive Holy Communion standing while standing at the railing. The same is true of the TLM in Savannah, those who can’t kneel at the railing, stand and easily receive that way. 

Why in the Name of God and all that is holy would a pope or a bishop created ill-feelings and resentment in parishioners who were allowed by a pope or a bishop to have the TLM only to have another pope of bishop take it away and the same is true about how and where to receive Holy Communion. 

And why would a bishop commit a mortal sin against charity and hospitality by insisting that those who choose to kneel to receive Holy Communion, cannot be offered a kneeler to do so, but must kneel on the hard floor and with no way to use their hands and arms to stand again! What the H—-?

Popes and bishops who reverse what other popes and bishops have allowed are not promoting unity in the Church—they are creating disunity, resentment, polarization, anger and anything but unity, but I digress!

By the way, many who kneel at the Ordinary Form Mass also receive in the hand!

I understand that when someone chooses a place to kneel where Holy Communion isn’t distributed, that is problematic, even if it is at a non-used altar railing. But, not allowing the use of the altar railing is mean-spirited and certainly not allowing a kneeler to be placed in front the the minister of Holy Communion to allow communicants to kneel if they so choose, is horrible and not Christian!


No comments: