
Archbishop Aurelio García Macías
In letter exchanges obtained by Messa in Latino, the faithful had appealed to Rome after Bishop Bodo (a bishop in Northern Italy) rejected their request for at least one Mass each month according to the 1962 Roman Missal. In a letter dated 17 July, Archbishop Aurelio García Macías, Under-Secretary of the Dicastery, told them that responsibility for implementing Traditionis custodesrests with the diocesan bishop and invited them to “maintain appropriate contact with your diocesan Ordinary”.
This is Diane Montagna’s commentary on Dispensations:
On the issue Pope Leo raised about the possibility of dispensations, it’s worth noting what prompted the need for bishops to obtain a dispensation from the Dicastery for Divine Worship.
Because diocesan bishops were using their legitimate power according to canon law (Canon 87 §1) to dispense from the provisions of Traditionis Custodes, Cardinal Roche found it necessary in February 2023 to obtain a rescript from Pope Francis to “ensure the correct application” of the motu proprio.
Henceforth, a bishop who wished to use Canon 87 §1 to dispense from Traditionis Custodes had to inform the Dicastery for Divine Worship, which would then decide either to affirm or overrule his decision. The rescript thus severely limited the freedom of bishops as “directors, promoters, and guardians of the entire liturgical life” in their dioceses (Canon 835 §1; cf. Christus Dominus, n. 15).
The rescript met with criticism from canonists who argued that Cardinal Roche had overstepped the mark and claimed a jurisdiction the Dicastery can’t have, because he was trying to control something that lies in the competency of the diocesan bishop.
Should he wish to, the Pope could revoke the rescript without rescinding Traditionis Custodes, thus restoring to local bishops the power to dispense from its provisions for the spiritual good of their dioceses.
No comments:
Post a Comment