Translate

Sunday, April 26, 2020

CAN WE START TO EVALUATE THE RELEVANCY OF THE CHURCH DURING THE CORONAVIRUS YET?

This photo accompanies an article from Rorate Caeli written by an Italian agnostic but with deep family Catholic roots, which causes me to think he is still Catholic at heart but disillusioned by the secularized post-Vatican II Catholic Church. He has an ax to grind but writes food for contemplation like the Most Holy Eucharist in a monstrance. You can read it HERE.


Things are opening up in two states where my feet are firmly planted, Georgia and South Carolina. But not the Catholic Church out of an abundance of caution and rightfully so. In Albany, Georgia in our diocese and a small town outside of Augusta in our Diocese, numerous cases of the Coronavirus can be traced to funerals held in churches that was the catalyst that led to numerous others contracting the disease and many dying. Albany is the “epicenter “ of the virus in Georgia. Outside of Augusta, even the pastor has since died of COVID-19 as a result of that funeral.

In Savannah on Thursday, Fr. Brett Brannen stood atop Memorial Hospital with others in medical uniform and masks and many below him at the entrance of the hospital. He offered prayer, homily and Benediction of the Most Blessed Sacrament and Fr. Brannen blessed Savannah with the Benediction north, south, east and west. It was covered by all the local TV stations and live-streamed and shared in a viral way.

What made this Benediction more viril, was the fact that others were with  Fr. Brannen. He was not a lone figure there with a server and one or two others. There may have been about 100 in attendance with most wearing masks and trying to spread out six feet apart, but not on the roof. Compare that image with the Lone Ranger in the photo above of Pope Francis. But at least it was Pope Francis and not an underling  priest, like Msgr. Marini.

Currently and perhaps through May, we cannot have Masses with more than a few people assisting on church property. Technically, we could have 10 to 15 in the congregation. In large church buildings, like St. Anne’s, people can spread out almost in two different states and still be in the same church.

And why is it wrong to ask for comparisons with Covid-19 and other flus currently experienced or the H1N1 virus a few years back which brought about for the first time these were allowed, restrictions on the Sign of Peace and the contagion producing Common Chalice? For example, in Augusta, a nursing home has had 80 residents and workers diagnosed with Covid-19. This was last week. There have been no reports of death there yet. But in a normal flu season, these same institutions as well as schools have flu viruses run rampant. In normal times some, if not many die, but there is no national news focus on it.

Should subsidiarity be put into place, which Vatican II mandated, (or did it actually mandate anything?) so that pastors can implement what civil law allows as restrictions are being eased in Georgia, South Carolina and even some states with Democrat governors, like Colorado, although that governor hasn’t come under scrutiny by the democrat media, only Georgia’s governor. Typical, no?

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

It's kind of shocking how quickly the Church folded. A panic over life and death grips the county and the Catholic Church's pastors have nothing to offer, because they feel they have no weapons in the fight. All the talk about the importance of the Mass and the sacraments evaporated overnight. Now we can watch Mass online and make a confession in our own homes. Oh, but don't forget to keep giving money to the parish even though it's been deemed "non-essential" and closed.

"Separation of Church and State" used to be used by liberals to decry a theocracy overseen by Bishops in shovel-hats. Now it's longed for by conservatives as the Church has become comfortable as the County Department of Social Justice.

Even the Pope is losing theological arguments on Twitter against a Bat PR account.
https://pjmedia.com/instapundit/368351/

Fr. Allan J. McDonald said...

The article I post above this one is very much in tune with the Agnostic writer for Rorate Caeil, but set to more generic terms. Yes the Church under Pope Francis is becoming more like an NGO, a non governmental organization but with a politicized agenda from the liberal left in terms of social justice, climate change etc. Pope Francis is entitled to speak about science and politics. He has free speech as the Supreme Pontiff. But outside of faith and morals and even canon law, we can chose to disagree with His Holiness when he comments on politics, the economy, the climate (weather) and the like. It holds no standing except in a politicized church which he has placed on steroids.

TJM said...

Father McDonald,

I think PF has almost no influence with faithful, young Catholics who view him and his pontificate as an aberration. They are going about their business as Catholics without him. He comes across, quite frankly, as not very bright.

Anonymous said...

Bee here:

In the article in Rorate Caeli the author comments that the Church under Pope Francis has "...de facto, discarded the bond with the transcendent..." and is "...in no way mediatrix between man and the Divinity." I don't know where this guy has been, but that didn't start with Pope Francis. That has been the agenda of the "Spirit of Vatican II" since the beginning. We're just in the end game now, where the SHTF, and the new modern Catholic Church has got nothin'. But the author of the article should know that, because obviously although he moves in Catholic circles, he himself rejected the transcendent and mystical long ago with the rest of oh so sophisticated and intelligent "modern men," otherwise he wouldn't be an agnostic. I guess he, like a lot of people who left the Church, assumed the hierarchy who didn't leave still believed in the transcendent God. Bad assumption.

Today the TLM gospel is "...I am the good shepherd. The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep. He who is a hired hand and not a shepherd, who does not own the sheep, sees the wolf coming and leaves the sheep and flees, and the wolf snatches them and scatters them. He flees because he is a hired hand and cares nothing for the sheep."

He flees because he is a hired hand, and cares nothing for the sheep.

Powerful insights, that ol' Jesus had. Cuts right to the chase.

But oh, so anachronistic for modern day Pharisees, er, I mean priests.

God bless.
Bee

Anonymous said...

"And why is it wrong to ask for comparisons with Covid-19 and other flus..."

It is not wrong to ask. It is wrong not to seek answers from medical professionals.

From Johns Hopkins Medicine:

CAUSE
COVID-19: Caused by one virus, the novel 2019 coronavirus, now called severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2, or SARS-CoV-2.

Flu: Caused by any of several different types and strains of influenza viruses.

TRANSMISSION
While both the flu and COVID-19 may be transmitted in similar ways (see the Similarities section above), there is also a possible difference: COVID-19 might be spread through the airborne route, meaning that tiny droplets remaining in the air could cause disease in others even after the ill person is no longer near.

ANTIVIRAL MEDICATIONS
COVID-19: Antiviral medications and other therapies are currently being tested to see if they can address symptoms.

Flu: Antiviral medications can address symptoms and sometimes shorten the duration of the illness.

VACCINE
COVID-19: No vaccine is available at this time, though it is in progress.

Flu: A vaccine is available and effective to prevent some of the most dangerous types or to reduce the severity of the flu.

DEATHS
The COVID-19 situation is changing rapidly. Since this disease is caused by a new virus, people do not have immunity to it, and a vaccine may be many months away. Doctors and scientists are working on estimating the mortality rate of COVID-19, but at present, it is thought to be higher than that of most strains of the flu.

These are the differences and they are significant.

TJM said...

Bee,

You nailed it

Sophia said...

Sophia here.

flu season of 2017/2018, was one of the deadliest- CDC reported 80,000 people died (and this is after approx. 45-50% of persons got the vaccine). Ironically, we do have a flu vaccine but relatively few people take it!

https://www.statnews.com/2018/09/26/cdc-us-flu-deaths-winter/

Four antibody (indication of recovery from illness) studies- 2 in California, one in Florida and one in New York, suggested that considerably more people had Covid-19 than number who had tested positive for it. Even with the limitations of the antibody tests (false positives and false negatives), this is great news. As the numerator of a fraction (in this case # of deaths) remains the same, while the denominator ( total # of cases) increases the fatality rate obviously decreases. This is already less than one and is expected to fall even more as more antibody tests as well as tests for the infection continue to increase! In addition, there is more good news-as more people get (preferably relatively mild or asymptomatic) infections and recover, protective "herd immunity" increases! Additionally as more and more people recover, they can choose to donate their "convalescent Plasma" which could turn out to be effective in treating others with the disease- studies are already underway! But Who could forget the famous Samaritan Purse Physician , Dr Kent Bradley whose "convalescent serum", after recovery from Ebola, was used to successfully treat another American physician-Rick Sacra who had also contracted that illness in Africa! The more we learn about this virus, the more optimistic we can become-news is mostly positive!

Deo Gracias! Alleluia! Alleluia

Anonymous said...

Father,
Just wondering if you had seen this: https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/boston-archdiocese-assembles-teams-of-priests-to-anoint-coronavirus-patients-96154