Translate

Wednesday, July 31, 2019

SPARE US O LORD USELESS REPETITION: PART II


Is the Responsorial psalm really or actually new and improved over the Gradual?

Here’s the Gradual for the Feast of St. Ignatius of Loyola :

The just shall flourish like the palm- tree; he shall grow up like the cedar of Libanus in the house of the Lord. (Ps. 91: 3) To show forth Thy mercy in the morning and Thy truth in the night. Glory to...

Alleluia, alleluia. Blessed is the man that endureth temptation; for when he hath been proved, he shall receive the crown of life. Alleluia.

Here is the Responsorial Psalm with six refrains:

Responsorial Psalm Ps 99:5, 6, 7, 9

R.(see 9c) Holy is the Lord our God.
All: Holy is the Lord our God.Extol the LORD, our God,
and worship at his footstool;
holy is he!
R. Holy is the Lord our God.
Moses and Aaron were among his priests,
and Samuel, among those who called upon his name;
they called upon the LORD, and he answered them.
R. Holy is the Lord our God.
From the pillar of cloud he spoke to them;
they heard his decrees and the law he gave them.
R. Holy is the Lord our God.
Extol the LORD, our God,
and worship at his holy mountain;
for holy is the LORD, our God.
R. Holy is the Lord our God.


Which one is less grating!

4 comments:

Victor said...

The gradual is succinct and to the point for meditation, which is probably why it became preferred over the unwieldy and loud responsorial psalm whose use did not last long in the history of the liturgy anyway. But with active participation above all else....

TJM said...

The whole Novus Ordo contradicts the notion of "noble simplicity." 3 options for the introductory Rite, 4 Eucharistic Prayers (others for Children's "Masses"), multiple dismissal options, and a 3 year lectionary. Noble simplicity, right.

Anonymous said...

For the unenlightened like myself, please distinguish "useless" repetition from "useful" repetition....

TJM said...

Maybe Fr. Martin LGBTSJ will insist this be added to the Liturgy so it is more "inclusive" for gays:

https://gloria.tv/article/UC9WtRDx9A2b1P6zLQ9xNMHi2