There are two commentaries very much related, one from Cardinal Fernandez and the other from Bishop Robert Mutsaerts although Mutsaerts’ commentary is very coherent and specific!
Cardinal Fernandez says this according to Infovaticano:
Fernández criticizes the priorities of progressives and conservatives
"No one is passionate about it": Fernández admits the scant impact of Venite ad me
The prefect attributes the scant interest in the document to the priorities that, in his view, predominate in different ecclesial sectors.
According to Fernández, more progressive bishops pay greater attention to structural changes and dialogue with society, while conservative sectors concentrate especially on the transmission of sexual morality. (My comment: While “conservatives” might seem to focus on sexuality, my experience of “conservatives” is that they focus on the 10 Commandments in general—but indeed, sexuality is vey personal and intimate to their own lives, be it a grace-filled moment or one of sin and guilt. But it is personal to them, from them, whereas social issues like war and peace, ways to care for the poor and the displaced are other than them and many feel helpless to solve these social problems apart from political affiliations or activism. It’s like the progressives who focus only on things external to them, rather than on Christ who is intimate with them and should be the center.)
The cardinal believes that both orientations relegate the proclamation of Jesus Christ and the personal experience of faith to a secondary place.
In this context, he maintained that Pope Francis’s call to renew the missionary proclamation of the kerygma has not produced significant changes in the pastoral projects of dioceses and movements.
In his opinion, this lack of response explains why the new document has not aroused particular enthusiasm either.
READ THE ENTIRE INFOVATICANO ARTICLE HERE.
Copied from Rorate Caeli, press title or read more for full great, common sense article, common sense so lacking in certain places in the Vatican and in chanceries:
Cardinal Roche's Threatening Language: Do Not Attend the TLM! But Why? The Church Need Not Forbid Its Past to Secure Its Future.
The Catholic Church prides (herself) on its universality, cherishes an impressive diversity of liturgical traditions, and regards that diversity as an expression of its riches. A Catholic may attend the divine liturgy according to the Byzantine tradition, the Maronite tradition, the Armenian tradition, or the Chaldean tradition. No one finds this in itself a threat to ecclesial unity. But the moment a Catholic wishes to attend Mass as it was celebrated for centuries in Rome, Paris, Amsterdam, and virtually the entire Latin Church, certain ecclesial authorities in Rome begin to grow uneasy.
Read more »
My final comments:
While Bishop Mutsaerts is more specific and coherent about it, Cardinal Fernandez also indicates that focusing in on the horizontal rather than the vertical is the problem in today’s Church.
When you understand the TLM, you realize that the focus is completely vertical, contemplative and other-worldly where the focus is on Christ—which then leads to the horizontal in the world—love of God and neighbor as the Church teaches the laity should carry out in the world, but the liturgy is other-worldly.
Not so, in many celebrations of the post-Vatican II Bugnini Mass. Often it is celebrated as though it’s a 1960’s Kumbaya Mass. There’s nothing transcendent about it. The problem is the Missal’s ambiguous General Instruction and the manipulation of the scant rubrics and rituals of the Mass by the priest and the laity during its celebration, such as casualness, clowning around and making Mass into a convivial “Sacred Meal” rather than the Holy Sacrifice it is. Revising the Bugnini Mass by giving it the TLM’s Order and rubrics would completely solve that problem without changing the vernacular or any of the prayers of the Mass (except the Introductory Rites).
Fernandez also indicates that progressive leaning bishops and dioceses think that more meetings, more structure, more talking (all horizontal by the way) are more important than a transcendent encounter with Christ who is the center of one’s life, not meetings! The disconnect for Cardinal Fernandez is that the synodal thingy, that no one likes and few care about, except that it is instrumentalized to make the Catholic Church like the Anglican Communion, is what the Vatican has been promoting for the last 14 years!
13 comments:
What does this new word 'instrumentalize' actually mean ?
I am so sick of the hippies running our church. Go away Cardinal Roche. Go away Cardinal Fernandez. Go away Cardinal Cupich, Tobin, McElroy etc. You are all awful. Go away you lot of vipers, please!
The boomers will be dead soon. pray for them.
"I do not think that many priests are saved, but that those who perish are far more numerous." - St John Chrysostom
This young bishop would be a rising star in a decent Church. He absolutely levels the intellectual dishonesty of The Roche!
What would they say to the majority of women wearing a chapel veil when entering a church in Asia, not just for mass. Not in the Philippines though, a majority catholic country. In Sri Lanka (Ceylon) 99.99% of females cover their heads. Catholics are 5.6% of the population. Christians overall are 6.9% of the population.
It is misleading to say that conservatives focus on sexual morality. They are outspoken on this only because it is being attacked by progressives who determined to dismantle it. The care of the poor is not an invention of Vatican II. The Church has been concerned about them since the beginning. How many charitable organizations were created by the Church in the centuries before Vatican II? In a healthy church the spiritual and corporal works of mercy go hand-in-hand. Care of the poor is not an exclusive domain of the progressives.
Greetings Father Mc Donald! Another incredibly pivotal election, once again involving the “non- negotiables” of abortion, euthanasia/ physician suicide, the sanctity of marriage, and harmful drug and mutilating treatment of gender confused minors is only a few days away! So would you please allow me to post a few items which are “off topic”?
The first is this homily, given by Bishop Thomas Olmstead, and repeated by one
of his priests, Fr.John Lankeit, at SS Simon and Jude Cathedral ahead of the 2016 elections, unequivocally and incontestably outlining the Catholic position on voting, given the primacy of place of abortion!
https://youtu.be/ephdVbbx8Z0?is=NlQp1msgQRTwpHeL
Here is another extremely compelling homily on the same topic given by Fr. Edward Meeks, Pastor of Christ the King Catholic Church, Towson Maryland, ahead of the 2020 elections!
These two homilies complement each other beautifully! You will not regret listening to both! It was an enormous pleasure to hear “ the truth and nothing but the truth” coming from both of these completely faithful, courageous, orthodox Shepherds with no dissembling, no regard for how their fellow clerics or superiors would react to what they said publicly!
https://youtu.be/965yYGF9BMQ
By this election cycle- given how much more grave, the situation has become- I was expecting similar homilies in every Catholic Church ahead of the current election!!!
And for the record, Cardinal Bernadine spent years trying to correct the misinterpretation and misuse of his “ Seamless Garment “ analogy by some unscrupulous ( my characterization) Catholic politicians and clerics to justify their political positions! Unfortunately, once these people saw how effectively they could use it to get away with the most unconscionable of positions, they continued to use it- even to the present day- despite his years of effort!
file:///var/mobile/Library/SMS/Attachments/8a/10/52A6251A-74EB-486A-B580-22364ED9077F/IMG_0642.PNG
https://youtu.be/965yYGF9BMQ
I for one, have lost respect for the intellectually dishonest and corrupt clerics like Cupich of Chicago. I will contribute my considerable wealth to the SSPX, FSSP, etc. I am done with these corrupt simpletons who are an embarrassment to Christ and His Church. Basta!
"...my considerable wealth..."
"Jesus sat down opposite the place where the offerings were put and watched the crowd putting their money into the temple treasury. Many rich people threw in large amounts. But a poor widow came and put in two very small copper coins, worth only a few cents. Calling his disciples to him, Jesus said, “Truly I tell you, this poor widow has put more into the treasury than all the others. They all gave out of their wealth; but she, out of her poverty, put in everything—all she had to live on.”
"The idea of worship in the Catholic Church is different from the idea of worship in the Protestant. ... It is the saying of holy images, or of the relative honour due to them, or of the invocation of Saints, or of the devotion to the Blessed Virgin, which constitutes the very life of the religion to the mind of the uneducated. You will find, for instance, an old hag worrying a crucifix, and you will say, 'How shocking!' But she is doing what she can; it is her way of showing love." St. John Henry Newman Apologia
Post a Comment