If only, if only, if only, Pope Leo had reestablished Ecclesia Dei as it was before Summorum Pontificum, it would have solved all the problems of this year’s Summorum Pontificum Pilgrimage.
If that pilgrimage had been coordinated by Ecclesia Dei and renamed the Ecclesia Dei Pilgrimage, the scandal of the “visuals” of the Vatican slamming the door in the face of Traditionalists would not have happened!
The Curial bishop or cardinal, the prefect for the reestablished Ecclesia Dei would have coordinated all events, made sure that there wasn’t any instrumentalization by those in the Traditionalist movement and the Prefect would have selected the celebrant for the Mass at St. Peter’s and all other events in the basilica.
For the love of God and all that is holy, reestablish and reconstitute Ecclesia Dei!
Here’s an AI description of the Ecclesia Dei established by St. John Paul II:
- Pontifical Commission: Established the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei" to help reintegrate traditionalist priests, seminarians, and religious communities wishing to remain in unity with Rome while keeping their traditional spiritual and liturgical forms. [1, 2]
- Liturgical Provision: Urged a "wide and generous application" of the pre-conciliar Roman liturgy (the 1962 Roman Missal) for Catholics attached to the traditional Latin Mass. [1, 2]
- Later Dissolution: Pope Francis dissolved the commission on January 17, 2019, transferring its duties directly to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. [1, 2]

13 comments:
I am an orthodox Catholic, but not a traditionalist. I would like a devout, reverent Novus Ordo with a great improvement on music. However, I was deeply disturbed by the treatment of so many TLM pilgrims at the Vatican. We are coming across as a vindictive, mean and cruel to people who are faithful Catholics while accepting of dissenters. The next day Pope Leo spoke of love of neighbor as the Vatican punished, publicly, people who's only crime is an affinity for the TLM. Where's the mercy, kindness and synodality of listening and accompanying other points of view within the Church. This is not a good way to evangelize.
This is the last gasp of the evil left in the Church. They are on an express train to Hell unless they repent and make amends.
That’s especially galling.
Nick
Like I said before, policy is policy. There’s a reason there’s no Ecclesia Dei commission, the original or reconstituted.
Nick
TJM, I would LOVE to agree with you and I pray I am wrong--but I think the unloyal opposition is only getting warmed up. If you think we are pariahs in the Church now, just wait...
I don’t think reestablishing Ecclesia dei will be a compromise. That is what set me on the path to the Vetus Ordo and I think it would bring us full circle back to Summorum Pontificum.
The SSPX applauded the suppression of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei.
Rorate Caeli blog highlight a "very positive aspect of the motu proprio..."
Both of the above notes correspond to the following from AI Overview:
"Yes, there were traditionalists who viewed the 2019 suppression of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei favorably..."
A few days prior to the commission's suppression, National Catholic Register had noted:
"The Vatican body aimed at keeping traditional Catholics united with the Successor of Peter looks likely to be suppressed, but sources suggest it could actually be a positive development."
In particular, Pope Francis, via the commission's suppression, had granted a golden opportunity to the SSPX.
National Catholic Register had noted that "the SSPX has viewed the Pontifical Commission as an obstacle to its negotiations with the Vatican and would prefer to deal directly with the prefect of the CDF..."
The SSPX favored Pope Francis' action in question.
https://fsspx.news/en/news/pontifical-commission-ecclesia-dei-suppressed-pope-francis-20841
The SSPX noted that Pope Francis' action in question 'has the merit of showing how this Pontifical Commission was originally founded on the condemnation of Archbishop Lefebvre and his work."
Pope Francis had offered to the TLM Movement a wonderful opportunity — the SSPX, in particular — that various trads squandered.
Anyway, I find it unimaginable that a trad would favor the commission's return.
Pax.
Mark Thomas
This could be true, but I doubt that the happiness of the SSPX is high on the Vatican's priority list right now.
Your red herrings are well past their date.
Nick
Speaking along this topic… Father, your quip about “traditionalists acting stupid” may need modification. Let alone reportage from Silere Non Possum, the Pillar, etc.
https://dianemontagna.substack.com/p/newly-published-letters-refute-vatican
Nick
I believe that as he is a holy man and wonderful pastor, Pope Leo XIV has great interest in steering the SSPX into orthodoxy.
I find it difficult to comprehend how that goal would be realized via the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei's restoration.
For that matter, it is difficult to understand why anyone interested in propagating the TLM would call for the commission's restoration.
Via AI Overview: Reasons why various trads despised the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei:
• The commission was created explicitly to deal with the fallout of an action Rome deemed schismatic (Lefebvre consecrating four bishops without a papal mandate).
• Traditionalists insisted that the crisis in the Church was doctrinal, not merely liturgical.
• They argued that Ecclesia Dei treated the desire for the Traditional Latin Mass as a mere "pastoral concession," "indult," or aesthetic preference rather than addressing what they saw as fundamental errors, novelties, and ambiguities introduced by the Second Vatican Council (such as ecumenism and religious liberty).
3. Subordination and Fear of Co-optation
• Communities operating under Ecclesia Dei (the so-called Ecclesia Dei institutes) were tied to the goodwill and oversight of post-conciliar Vatican dicasteries...
• Hardline critics argued that placing traditional groups under a Vatican-managed commission compromised their ability to freely critique modern theological and liturgical trends.
• Critics within traditionalist circles often viewed the commission as toothless or rhetorical.
• They pointed out that Ecclesia Dei frequently failed to compel hostile local diocesan bishops to actually implement traditional mass permissions (prior to Benedict XVI’s Summorum Pontificum), leaving traditional faithful at the mercy of unsympathetic local hierarchies.
=======
Pope Francis' suppression of the commission favored trads greatly. He had opened the door wide for trads, such as those attached to the SSPX, to ensure their full communion with the Church.
That was a wonderful decision by Pope Francis.
Anyway, there has not been even a hint from Pope Leo XIV that he will revive the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei.
But should he do so, I would expect an outcry from trads.
Pax.
Mark Thomas
Oh look, “pax” follows the worst faith description of all those who wish to propagate the TLM that MT can get AI to mindlessly spew out for him.
I didn’t think Mt’s comments could get worse, but MTAI has done it again. Is there anything AI can’t do?!
Nick
Post a Comment