Translate

Tuesday, July 9, 2024

REFORM IN CONTINUITY: IS IT STILL HAPPENING IN NOVUS ORDO PARISHES?



As you know, as a senior priest, I reside on Hilton Head Island and assist in three parishes, two in the Beaufort County area of the Diocese of Charleston and once a month in Savannah for the TLM. 

Holy Family Church, parish to gators who are greeters, caters primarily to the tourist population on the Island, as we residents call it. There is a strong parish community too but the tourists out number the parishioners quite significantly during the summer. 

Novus Ordo parishes throughout the country have done a great job with tourists that come to the Island and not only make sure they attend Sunday Mass, but many also attend Holy Family’s daily Mass. 

There are a significant number of young tourists at Sunday and daily Mass, especially college age young people.

What I have noticed is that a great number of the late teen and early 20’s Catholic tourists normally kneel to receive Holy Communion. That tells me that they are doing so in their Novus Ordo parishes. They also take advantage of going to Confession during the weekdays as well, when they are here. 

Renewal of the Novus Ordo Mass in continuity with the TLM is happening still and after TC. This is great news and the Catholics, especially the young ones, formed by the so-called “reform of the reform” parishes are producing wonderful, zealous and strong Catholics. 

My prayer is that bishops will be as zealous at implementing Pope Francis’ document on the liturgy which came out after TC as they are in rigorously implementing TC! This is one thing that the pope wrote in his liturgy document DESIDERIO DESIDERAVI which you can read HERE:

23. Let us be clear here: every aspect of the celebration must be carefully tended to (space, time, gestures, words, objects, vestments, song, music…) and every rubric must be observed. Such attention would be enough to prevent robbing from the assembly what is owed to it; namely, the paschal mystery celebrated according to the ritual that the Church sets down. But even if the quality and the proper action of the celebration were guaranteed, that would not be enough to make our participation full.


54. If it is true that the ars celebrandi is required of the entire assembly that celebrates, it is likewise true that ordained ministers must have a very particular concern for it. In visiting Christian communities, I have noticed that their way of living the liturgical celebration is conditioned — for better or, unfortunately, for worse — by the way in which their pastor presides in the assembly. We could say that there are different “models” of presiding. Here is a possible list of approaches, which even though opposed to each other, characterize a way of presiding that is certainly inadequate: rigid austerity or an exasperating creativity, a spiritualizing mysticism or a practical functionalism, a rushed briskness or an overemphasized slowness, a sloppy carelessness or an excessive finickiness, a superabundant friendliness or priestly impassibility. Granted the wide range of these examples, I think that the inadequacy of these models of presiding have a common root: a heightened personalism of the celebrating style which at times expresses a poorly concealed mania to be the centre of attention. Often this becomes more evident when our celebrations are transmitted over the air or online, something not always opportune and that needs further reflection. Be sure you understand me: these are not the most widespread behaviours, but still, not infrequently assemblies suffer from being thus abused.


7 comments:

Amont said...

Father, in my part of the world young people(and some not so young)will kneel.Requests for a kneeler are dismissed ; "the elderly will trip over them ..etc" There is a general attitude of reverence and piety among many young people , sadly rejected by older Catholics as passe.

Bob said...

Many/most of the folk kneeling likely show Latin mass exposure, but also imagine the recent Eucharistic Congress advertising blitz from the USCCB has (finally) had some parishes instituting kneeling that were not doing so, where opposition to kneeling at parish and diocese level toned down...

In my experience, most folk kneeling are doing so unencourged by any parish or bishop, and them merely trying to find meaning in what otherwise seems empty...

How many are there praying before and after mass, preparing themselves for reception of the sacrament, and giving loving thanks afterward for that gift?...you know, actually showing they are trying to love God above anything else?...a few devoted older folk and some younger folk looking for meaning?...if that many?

Nick said...

Call me a cynic, bishops will implement whatever gets the Vatican to stop twisting their arms. I.e., TC will get full implementation, other documents on the liturgy, not so much.

Nick

monkmcg said...

Thanks for the reverent manner in which you celebrate the NO; but you are among a small minority of priests who do so. More often we get: ad libbed prayers, "Jimmy Kimmel" style commentary, and the worst the Breaking Bread hymnal has to offer. I have even been refused the eucharist because I knelt to receive (on vacation in a different diocese). Two big problems with the NO are: 1) so many options (valid and invented) that you never know what kind of Mass to expect; 2) the focus on the priest rather than on God during prayer.

Fr. Allan J. McDonald said...

Monkmcg, your critique is correct and that is why we need a “reform of the reform” but in continuity with the TLM. If only all those who embraced the TLM and had it flourishing, only to have it canceled, would then turn their energies to the proper celebration of the NO, that would have a trickle down effect as I have seen with tourists on Hilton Head!

Timothy said...

Father McDonald,
very happy to hear what you are trying to do but you are a unicorn. we are converts (2003) and for our first 6 years in the church we had a good Priest that was into the reform of the reform and taught and was initiating what the VII documents actually said. After our Priest was moved, right after installing an alter rail(which is no longer used), we worked tirelessly with 4 priests and 2 bishops over the next 12 years and made little or no progress. every priest was one step forward 2 steps back. finally in 2022 we gave up and just went to the TLM. Now the only remaining TLM in our Diocese (1 pm Sunday, over an hour drive each way) is likely to be shut down in a few months. What then?? we will drive 2 hours to attend a beautiful TLM with the SSPX in a neighboring Diocese. We will not even have a twinge of conscience about the SSPX. They care about the Catholic Faith and the people.
WE pray for the Pope and our Bishop and Priests with all the sincerity that we can muster but I believe most of them are headed for HELL!! for what they are doing. Some one should warn them!!
Saint Michael the Arch Angel defend us in battle!!

Susan, TOF said...

Father, I am so happy to read your article!

At my Novus Ordo parish in Akron, Ohio, we have many college-aged young adults at daily and weekend Masses, as well as at Confession and Adoration, who are quite devout and faithful - a real example to me. My parish is the home of the University of Akron Newman Center and FOCUS (Fellowship of Catholic University Student) missionaries, and my pastor is their chaplain. He is also relatively young (39) and is pastor to our sister parish.

In the 6 years Father has been our pastor, we have had numerous vocations after *decades* with no vocations. Presently, one young man is in the Benedictine monastery in Oklahoma in priestly formation, one young man has completed his first year at the Diocesan seminary and will start his second year next month, and one of the members of the Newman Center will be entering the seminary next month, having graduated from the University this past January. In addition, one young lady professed as a Nashville Dominican a couple of years ago, and another young lady from the Newman Center made her first vows as a Mercedarian Sister about a year ago. And two teenaged brothers who serve Mass requested Father to escort them and their parents to the seminary for a tour, along with a visit to our good bishop.

Father has promoted reverence and dignity among the altar servers and all of us at Mass. When he arrived, the Newman Center students asked for monthly Adoration, and he happily obliged, adding a homily and Confession and opening it up to both parishes. On June 24, my parish hosted a Mass in honor of the Eucharistic Revival at our local AA-league ballpark, presided by our bishop. We had over 900 in attendance, with at least 15 priests, several deacons, 12 young servers, and 4 local seminarians. It was followed by a formal Eucharistic Procession with the Blessed Sacrament to our parish church and concluded with Adoration.

I thank you for recognizing the reverence among our young adults. From what I have seen, most of them are far more concerned with being faithful Catholics than in protesting on campus, going to beer bashes, and participating in unwholesome activities. Our students, instead of going to the beach for Spring Break, instead volunteer at soup kitchens, work at home renovations for the elderly and poor, and help in practical ways around our parish.

God will never abandon us, but we have to do our part to instill and pass on the Faith to the next generation. Thank you, Father, for all you do!