Translate

Sunday, March 2, 2025

YIKES! WHAT A CONTRAST! DID VATICAN II MANDATE THIS?

 Saint Raphael Catholic Church in New Orleans was devastated by Hurricane Katrina and its aftermath.

The parish closed for a while due to the damage but re-emerged as the church building for a new parish of consolidated parishes. 

The new parish name is Transfiguration.

I visited St. Raphael in the very early 1980’s shortly after my ordination as I had a  seminary classmate who was assigned there. 

This is what it looked like then:

After Katrina and the closing of parishes into one merged parish that used the once flooded St. Raphael Church but renamed Transfiguration, this is how it was renovated:

YIKES!

3 comments:

TJM said...

Think of all the money that could have been used for the poor instead of turning a perfectly acceptable sanctuary into a tasteless clutter

ByzRus said...

I suppose, relative to RC books, it serves the purpose and doesn't invalidate the sacraments. If not for the sanctuary lamp, I would not have recognized the tabernacle as such. Indeed, this is a style.

So often, we hear "don't do x so it doesn't take away from the altar". There is so little there to remove.

Space that inspires? I guess that which provides inspiration is derived from the perspective of the individual. This doesn't inspire much in me and the off-centeredness is irritating. Ideology at the expense of Catholicity? Rupture? I just don't know what to think here. What I do know is in certain RC diocese around me, and to their credit, this design would NOT have been approved for execution. I feel badly for children. They are going to grow up thinking the Jesus, the Church etc. is off-center and they'll likely just drift away as so many do. Off-center vocations? Probably not; but, you never know.

The priest in the link below looks as though he is mentally redesigning this "space". I would be.

I thank goodness this sort of presentation is just not permitted in my rite/Church.

To see more:
https://neworleanschurches.com/transfiguration/index.htm

Mike Lutz said...

Something that immediately caught my eye was the severe reduction in size of the crucifix. Sad.