Both Austria and Ireland have associations of priests who dissent from the Church's teachings. Bishops in those two countries have tried heroically to keep them in the fold of the priesthood and Church, but now there appears to be a tipping point and that tipping point is coming from Pope Francis and his orthodoxy. He approved of the excommunication of two dissident Catholics laity in Austria for corrupting the sacraments of the Church and our teachings. Excommunication, especially public excommunication, is a clarion call to those who are excommunicated to repent and return to the full communion of the Church. It is quite pastoral as it has to do with the salvation of those who are excommunicated for taking a path of heterodoxy and division in the Church which go lead them to eternal damnation.
Statement of the Austrian Pastors’ Intitiative on the Excommunication of Martha and Gert Heizer
We,
the Austrian Pastors’ Initiative, are deeply concerned about the
actions the Church’s leadership has taken against Martha and Gert
Heizer. The Excommunication was levied against two Church members who
have worked for the reform of our Church with great passion, commitment,
and energy.
This decision is a fatal signal for all who are hoping,
together with Pope Francis, for a kind Church that is close to the
people. What kind of signal is being sent by a Church that punishes the
perpetrators of sexual abuse among its ranks less severely than Church
members who, by the way they practice their faith, express their great
sufferings at the fringes of the Church’s existing set of rules? (My comment: This is the same lame, sorry excuse that many use to justify their disloyalty to the teachings of Christ and believe that two wrongs make a right, that is because the Church failed to act in a timely way with the abuse crisis, the Church should do the same with other lesser offenses and never make course corrections. This sound so very familiar to me, especially in the last week here in Macon!)
The
opinions may differ about the step that Martha and Gert Heizer have
taken in celebrating the Eucharist without a priest. It may be seen as a
prophetic step that points the way to an overall reform of the Church
or it may not be seen that way. The Pastors’ Initiative sees Eucharist
and priestly office as belonging together – as long as the Church is
able to provide priests to its communities, who share peoples’ lives and
share their journey of faith. (My comment: here the priests show their true heterodox colors, and betray a theology that developed in Europe in the early 1970's and long thought to have been put to rest. Pope Francis knows of this silly stuff and is acting in the most juridical way possible sending a message to the entire Church that it will not be tolerated. Pope Francis has judged these heterodox Catholics and by extension these heterodox priests). But with present developments in the
Church fewer and fewer communities have the option of a Eucharistic
celebration on Sundays with an ordained priest being present. Martha and
Gert Heizer are touching a sore spot: the Eucharist, the mass, the
central celebration of our faith and of life as a community, is becoming
increasingly rare due to the shortage of priests. For this reason the
church reform movements have advocated for a long time that the
priesthood should be open to married men and women and that the with the
participation of the citizens of the Church new forms of leading the
communities should be developed.
The
“Ex-Communication” of Martha and Gert Heizer does indeed signal the end
of communication in the sense of an open and fair dispute. This way of
proceeding is not only completely out of proportion, but it shows the
inability of the leadership of our Church to settle differences of
opinion and conflicts in accordance with the gospel in a kind and loving
way. This is a failure that nobody can be proud of. (My comment: I think all heterodox Catholics use the same manipulation that small children use with their parents when they can't get their way, that somehow their love is called into question. If you take a strong stance, like Pope Francis has in this case, you don't really love and you are not really Christ-like and you really don't understand the Gospel. How many have said this around the world and here in Macon concerning the Mt. de Sales corrective course adjustment in reestablishing Catholic identity as it concerns sexual morality and marriage?)
We appeal
to all persons in leadership positions to reverse the Excommunication
and to take up instead an honest and fair dialogue with the church
reform movements about the future of the Church. (My comment: why does this sound oh, so familiar to me????)
The Pastors’s Initiative
signed by Helmut Schüller, President (He is a dissident priest who was a monsignor but stripped of that title. He heads up other dissident priests in Austria. They may well be excommunicated in the near future and they now know it because of Pope Francis judgements concerning these kinds of Catholics!)
signed by Helmut Schüller, President (He is a dissident priest who was a monsignor but stripped of that title. He heads up other dissident priests in Austria. They may well be excommunicated in the near future and they now know it because of Pope Francis judgements concerning these kinds of Catholics!)